• Skip to main content
AlgaeBarn

AlgaeBarn

Marine Aquariums Made Easy!

  • Sign In
  • Cart
    • Shop See All
      • Ultimate Packs See All
      • Ultimate Refugium Starter
      • Clam Keeper Kits
      • Ultimate Ecopack
      • Mandarin Feeder Kit
      • Hair Algae Killer Kit
      • See All Ultimate Packs
      • Live Foods See All
      • Copepods
        • Ecopods
        • 5280 Pods
        • Galaxy Pods
        • Poseidon's Feast
        • Tisbe Pods
        • Tig Pods
      • Food Combos
        • Ecopods & Phyto
        • Galaxy Pods & Phyto
        • Poseidon's & Phyto
        • Tig Pods & Phyto
        • Tisbe Pods & Phyto
      • Phytoplankton
        • Oceanmagik
      • Brine Shrimp
        • Simple Brine
        • Nano Brine Shrimp
      • Most Popular Products See All
        • Galaxy Pods 5 Species Copepod Blend

          Galaxy Pods

          $66 – $139
          Shop Now
        • Ecopods 4 Pack Special

          $99
          Shop Now
        • Galaxy Pods & Phyto Combo

          $80
          Shop Now
        • 5280 Pods

          $45
          Shop Now
      • Macroalgae See All
      • Clean Macro Series
        • Clean Chaeto
        • Clean Sea Lettuce
        • Clean Green Ogo
        • Clean Mocha Ogo
        • Clean Mocha Spike Sphere
        • Pom Pom
        • Red Ogo
        • Red Spike Sphere
        • Red Spaghetti
        • Red Mangrove
      • Premium Rare Macro
        • Leafy Ogo
        • Blue Hypnea
        • Dragon's Tongue
        • Thick Ogo
      • Most Popular Products See All
        • Clean Chaeto

          $20 – $65
          Notify Me When in Stock
        • Clean Sea Lettuce

          $20 – $95
          Shop Now
        • Red Ogo

          $20 – $80
          Notify Me When in Stock
        • Red Mangrove

          $13
          Shop Now
      • Captive Bred Fish See All
      • Gobies
        • Green Mandarin
        • Court Jester Goby
        • Watchman Goby
        • White Spotted Goby
      • AngelFish
        • Biota Coral Beauty
        • Maculosus Angel
        • Majestic Angel
        • Swallowtail Angel
      • Tangs
        • Yellow Tang
        • Blue Tang
      • More Species
        • Grammas
        • FileFish
        • Blennies
        • Damsel
        • ClownFish
        • RabbitFish
      • Most Popular Products See All
        • Blue Mandarin

          BIOTA Green Mandarin

          $99
          Shop Now
        • ORA Neon Goby

          $35
          Shop Now
        • Captive Bred Yellow Tangs by BIOTA

          BIOTA Yellow Tang

          $239
          Notify Me When in Stock
        • ORA Premium Picasso

          $145 – $300
          Shop Now
      • Captive Bred Invertebrates See All
      • Clams
        • Ora Derasa Clam
        • Squamosa Clam
        • Ora Gigas Clam
        • Ora Maxima Clam
        • Ora Hippopus Clam
      • Shrimp
        • Ora Peppermint Shrimp
        • Harlequin Shrimp
      • Snails
        • Cerith Snails
        • Trochus Snail
        • Nassarius Snails
      • Urchins
        • Ora Tuxedo Urchin
        • Ora Pincushion Urchin
      • Most Popular Products See All
        • Animated gif of peppermint shrimp

          ORA Peppermint Shrimp

          $49 – $119
          Shop Now
        • 10 Cerith Snails

          Cerith Snail

          $25 – $39
          Shop Now
        • pincushion urchin lytechinus variegatus reef safe and captive bred by ora for sale at algaebarn

          ORA Pincushion Urchin

          $29 – $55
          Shop Now
        • Gold Maxima Clam Bed

          ORA Maxima Clam

          $50 – $90
          Notify Me When in Stock
      • Corals See All
      • LPS Corals
        • Biota Pearl Bubble
        • ORA Pearl Bubble
        • ORA Marshall Island Goniopora
        • ORA Marshall Island Hammer
      • SPS Corals
        • ORA Pearlberry Acropora
        • ORA Micronesian Imperial Acropora
        • ORA Turquoise Acropora
        • ORA Micronesian Yellow Porites
      • Soft Corals
        • BIOTA White Polyp Toadstool
        • ORA Long Polyp Leather Coral
        • ORA Silver Xenia
        • ORA Pulsing Xenia
      • Frag Packs
      • Most Popular Products See All
        • Biota Pearl Bubble Coral

          $60
          Shop Now
        • ORA Pearlberry Acropora

          $290
          Shop Now
        • BIOTA White Polyp Toadstool

          $65
          Shop Now
      • Additives & Bacteria See All
      • Live Cultures & Bacteria
        • Turbostart 900 Saltwater
        • Aquarium Cycle Kit
        • Coralline Algae
        • PNS Yellosno
        • PNS Probio™
      • Additives & Chemicals
        • Nitrocycle
        • Clarifier
        • Fritz A.C.C.R
        • Fritz RPM Salt
      • Most Popular Products See All
        • Mandarin Feeder Kit by Algaebarn

          Mandarin Feeder Kit

          $66
          Shop Now
        • MarinePure 10 Cubes

          2″ Cubes

          $5 – $99
          Shop Now
        • Coralline Algae in a Bottle, In Pink or Purple!

          Coralline Algae

          $22 – $44
          Shop Now
        • Ultimate Refugium Starter Pack

          $120 – $450
          Shop Now
      • Aquarium Supplies See All
      • Fuge Lighting
        • AI Fuge 16HD Light
        • Kessil A360X Fuge Light
        • Kessil H160
        • Kessil H80
        • Chaetomax
      • Biomedia
        • Marinepure Gems
        • Marinepure Rocks
        • Marinepure Plate
        • Marinepure Cubes
        • Marinepure Spheres
      • Foods
        • Dragon Roe
        • Simple Brine
        • Can'O Cyclops
        • Benereef™
        • Fresco Cyclops
      • Rock & Sand
        • Dry Rock
        • Clam Rocks
      • Most Popular Products See All
        • Mandarin Feeder Kit by Algaebarn

          Mandarin Feeder Kit

          $66
          Shop Now
        • MarinePure 10 Cubes

          2″ Cubes

          $5 – $99
          Shop Now
        • Coralline Algae in a Bottle, In Pink or Purple!

          Coralline Algae

          $22 – $44
          Shop Now
        • Ultimate Refugium Starter Pack

          $120 – $450
          Shop Now
      • CADE Aquariums See All
      • Reef Series
        • CADE REEF 500 S2
        • CADE REEF 600 S2
        • CADE REEF 900 S2
        • CADE REEF 1200 S2
        • CADE REEF 1500 S2
        • CADE REEF 1800 S2
        • CADE REEF 2100 S2
      • Frag Series
        • CADE Frag 600 S2/F
        • CADE Frag 900 S2/F
        • CADE Frag 1200 S2/F
        • CADE Frag 1500 S2/F
      • Peninsula Series
        • CADE Peninsula 1200 S2/P
        • CADE Peninsula 1500 S2/P
        • CADE Peninsula 1800 S2/P
      • Most Popular Products See All
        • CADE REEF 2100 S2

          $7,225
          Shop Now
        • CADE Peninsula 1500 S2/P

          $5,525
          Shop Now
        • CADE REEF 1200 S2

          $4,125
          Shop Now
        • CADE Frag 900 S2/F

          $3,275
          Shop Now
    • Contests Win Free Aquarium Supplies!
      No Purchase Necessary*
    • Top Deals Huge Savings!
    • AlgaeBarn Heroes Discount for Military,
      First Responders and more!
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contact
  • Shipping
You are here: Home / Beginners Education / Aquarium Maintenance / Sand Stirrers and Detritivores in Reef Aquaria

Sand Stirrers and Detritivores in Reef Aquaria

by Kenneth Wingerter

These days, a pretty good number of aquarists (a majority of them, perhaps) prefer bare-bottom tanks. Bare, as in, no sand or gravel on the tank floor. Just as these folks opt for bare-bottom display tanks, they opt for bare-bottom refugia. The basis of this trend is a fear of detritus–specifically, that substrates attract and accumulate detritus. Now, detritus does kind of suck, as it looks gross and stores nutrients that can (as they are released) contribute to unwanted algal growth. At least in theory, if you don’t have a substrate, particulate organic matter cannot easily get trapped on the bottom, and so your tank will be cleaner.

This all deserves a closer look. And some deeper thought. 

Sand Stirrers and the limits of mechanical filtration

In bare-bottom tanks, just as in tanks with a substrate, detritus is eventually mineralized (broken down) into excess nutrients and dissolved organic waste. “No problem,” the bare-bottom proponent might say, “I’ll just go heavy on the mechanical filtration.” Fair enough, so long as mechanical filter media are thoroughly rinsed on a regular basis (i.e. daily), very little of entrapped particulate organics can mineralize much. Effective means of nutrient export, right?

Yes and no. Consider first of all that mechanical filtration is indiscriminate. It removes all particles down to some particular size–both bad and good. This means that in addition to all that rinsing, you’ll also have to mess with it (i.e. remove it or somehow divert flow around it) whenever you feed. Otherwise, all of those pricey fish foods and coral foods you add will almost instantly become “waste.” Top-dollar detritus.

But an even bigger concern about aggressive mechanical filtration is pod mortality. Think about it… A coarse mechanical filter medium that cannot strain particles of less than, say, 75 microns is pretty much worthless. Yet, finer media that strain anything smaller than 75 microns will remove most adult copepods and even many copepod nauplii. They’ll be harder yet on larger pods like amphipods. No, we’re not saying that mechanical filtration outright decimates an entire pod population. Nor do we claim that pods simple perish upon first contact with a mechanical filter medium. 

What we are saying is that fine mechanical filtration does trap some (and potentially a lot of) pods and therefore limits their population size. Really “good” mechanical filters can completely eliminate copepod species that undergo a pelagic adult life stage. See the vicious circle here? You keep a bare-bottom tank to enhance the collection of detritus in your mechanical filter, which you install because you have a bare-bottom tank–to the detriment of copepods, which are your best weapon against detritus in the first place!

At this point, we present an alternative (and dare we say more natural?) approach; keeping a substrate, using only super-coarse mechanical filtration (if any) and promoting the degradation of detritus by detritivores such as (but not limited to) copepods. 

The hitch? You need a crew of so-called sand-stirring organisms. Stirrers accomplish two important tasks. Firstly, their excavations encourage the release of organic matter from deep within the substrate. These wastes are otherwise inaccessible to detritivorous animals not just because of layer of sand above them, but also because they may be situated in anoxic areas. This leads to the second job, which is aerating the substrate surface, thereby increasing the depth at which aerobic detritivores can safely forage. 

Substrates=Reef food factories

There is a very large diversity of detritivorous reef critters. As one might expect, many of these sediment-dwellers are tiny. The little guys include microcrustaceans such as harpacticoid copepods, cerith snails, various worms, etc. There are many larger detritivores as well. These range from sand-sifting gobies to sand-sifting sea cucumbers. 

It almost all of these cases, the creatures are not really eating the detritus to eat the detritus; rather, they are going after the rich microfauna that is associated with the detritus (bacteria, fungi, protozoa, etc.). The smallest detritivores just crawl around within the sand and gobble up teeny particles as they find them. Larger ones, however, swallow up big mouthfuls of sand, detritus and all. They then either strain out the goodies and spit the sand back out, or they actually eat the sand, digest the goodies, and then poop the sand. The evidence of this latter group is sometimes observed over the sand bed surface every morning in the form of distinct formed, clean, white sandy pellets.

Not all sand stirrers are detritivores and not all detritivores are sand stirrers. For example, certain fish (e.g. jawfish) and certain shrimp (e.g. pistol shrimp) build elaborate borrows. These burrows help aerate deeper parts of the sand bed through irrigation (that is, movement and exchange of waters between the top and bottom portions of the burrow). This allows other creatures (especially detritivores) to forage deeper in the immediate area, and so compliments and promotes the activities of sand stirrers.

Some creatures help to keep the sand bed clean even without doing any stirring. These range from pods to detritivorous fish (e.g. court jester blennies). The reason is pretty simple: Where detritus is consumed at the substrate surface, less detritus can settle deep within the substrate.  

Basically, having a large and diverse clean-up crew and a diverse team of sand stirrers can significantly reduce the need for mechanical filtration, if not eliminate the need altogether. Some creatures will fill just one of these roles, and others will fill both. What’s important is that the aquarist assembles an ecological community that breaks down detritus as quickly and thoroughly as possible–the widest size particle range, the most types, in all locations of the system. This encourages rapid recycling, which encourages large populations of both zooplankton and bacterioplankton, which are both important components of the coral diet.

Related Posts

Does CADE Make Good Aquariums for Beginners?

Choosing the right aquarium system as a beginner can be an overwhelming task. The honest truth is that this decision has the potential to make a crucial

Read More about Does CADE Make Good Aquariums for Beginners?

Can I Put Dry Rock in a Reef Tank?

The relationship with aquascaping the reef tank can be a complicated one! The hobby of reef keeping has advanced significantly. Back in the early days of

Read More about Can I Put Dry Rock in a Reef Tank?
Ultimate Galaxy Pack

Introducing the Ultimate Galaxy Pack

We would like to introduce our newest feeding system – The Ultimate Galaxy Pack! As reef keepers, we know all too well that coral reef ecosystems are among

Read More about Introducing the Ultimate Galaxy Pack

Didn't find what you were looking for?

Browse the AlgaeLab by Category

  • Advanced Education
  • Beginners Education
  • CADE Aquariums
  • Captive Bred Fish
  • Clean Up Crew
  • Company News
  • Copepods
  • Corals
  • Freshwater
  • Freshwater Aquariums
  • Intermediate Education
  • Invertebrates
  • Live foods
  • Macroalgae
  • Phytoplankton
  • Product Info
  • Refugium Education
  • Rock and Substrate
  • Saltwater Aquariums
  • Wholesale

Company

  • About Us
  • The AlgaeLab Blog
  • Our Team
  • FAQ

Get in Touch

  • Contact Us
  • AOA Claim Form
  • Press Inquiries
  • Call Us: 772-444-7637

Policies

  • Legendary AOA Guarantee
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy

Other

  • Store Locator
  • Wholesale & B2B inquired
  • Business Location

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Join our mission to build a more sustainable aquarium hobby, one tank at a time!

Copyright 2022, AlgaeBarn LLC - Live Copepods and Phytoplankton

adroll_adv_id = "RWFLKG57L5GR7KGYSOEUOK"; adroll_pix_id = "CH2QRUFHXZELLLCMHAB5GI"; adroll_version = "2.0"; adroll_current_page = "other"; adroll_currency = "USD"; adroll_language = "en_US";
0

Your Cart is Empty